Judge weighs Anthropic's fair use defense against music publishers
A California federal judge heard Anthropic's bid to dismiss lyric copyright claims and questioned whether the case could reach trial first.
By Standard Topic. AI-generated from the reporting listed under Coverage. Published . Updated .
This story is no longer being updated. It reflects reporting up to .
What happened
On Wednesday, US District Judge Eumi Lee in San Jose, California, heard arguments in a copyright lawsuit brought by music publishers including Universal Music Group against AI company Anthropic over the use of song lyrics to train its Claude chatbot. Anthropic argued that the use is fair use, and the judge appeared open to that defense, saying AI-produced "mash-up" lyrics might qualify. The publishers countered that Claude's lyrics dilute real lyrics.
Timeline
- Oct 21, 6:00 AM ET: Judge Eumi Lee was scheduled to hear arguments in the lyrics copyright case in San Jose, California.
- Oct 21, 6:35 PM ET: The judge pressed both sides to help her decide whether the case would become the first AI copyright case to reach trial.
- Oct 21, 9:43 PM ET: After a daylong hearing, the judge said AI-generated mash-up lyrics might constitute fair use while questioning the scope of the case.
- Oct 22, 11:56 AM ET: Music publishers argued that Claude's lyrics were diluting real lyrics in the latest proceedings.
Coverage
- Claude’s lyrics are diluting real lyrics, say music publishers in latest Anthropic proceedings (completemusicupdate.com)
- Anthropic's Lyric 'Mash Up' May Be Fair Use, Judge Says (law360.com)
- Anthropic, Music Publishers Spar Over AI’s Harm, Aim in IP Case (news.bloomberglaw.com)
- Anthropic, music publishers square off on 'fair use' defense in AI copyright case (TradingView)
- Anthropic, music labels to make key arguments in AI training case (TradingView)
More from Technology & AI
- China puts humanoid robots to work serving food and sorting parcels
- Newsom proposes sweeping AI safety rules for Washington
- Google releases Gemini 4 Neon AI model with million-token context
- Microsoft and Intel widen their cloud chip partnership
- Google DeepMind rolls out Genie 4 to select subscribers
- AI helped AMD shorten chip design work, OpenAI says